top of page

Five mistakes South African founders make

Oct 27
3 min read

Most founders don't start businesses because they are excited about shareholders' agreements. Legal housekeeping tends to come later. Sometimes much later.


Unfortunately, legal problems usually become apparent at exactly the wrong moment: when an investor arrives, a founder wants out, the business needs funding, or somebody discovers that what everyone thought had been agreed was never actually agreed.

Here are five mistakes I see repeatedly.


1. Doing a 50/50 deal because it feels fair


Two equally enthusiastic founders. Fifty per cent each. A 50/50 company isn't inherently a bad idea, but one with no sensible mechanism for resolving deadlock probably is.

Founders should decide at the beginning what happens when they cannot agree on an important question.


Such conversations can feel pessimistic when everybody is excited about the business, but considerably less so three years later when the founders are no longer speaking.


2. Neglecting the shareholders' agreement


A properly drafted shareholders' agreement should deal with matters such as control, funding, reserved decisions, issuing new shares, transfers, departures, death or disability, restraints where appropriate, valuation and exit arrangements.


In South Africa, it must also be considered together with the company's Memorandum of Incorporation. Section 15(7) of the Companies Act provides that a shareholders' agreement must be consistent with the Act and the MOI, and that an inconsistent provision is void to the extent of the inconsistency.


Downloading a shareholders' agreement from the internet and hoping for the best is therefore not the saving of legal fees it sometimes appears to be.


3. Assuming the company owns the intellectual property


Imagine that a founder develops software before the company exists, a freelancer designs the brand, and somebody's friend designs and builds the first website.

Then an investor asks a simple question:

Does the company actually own all of this?


Intellectual property ownership should be sorted out early and documented properly, particularly where the value of the business resides in software, designs, content, processes, know-how or a brand.


The time to clean up the chain of title is not during an investment or acquisition due diligence when somebody on the other side has already spotted the problem.


4. Giving away equity without deciding what happens if somebody leaves


Early-stage equity feels inexpensive because there isn't much money in the business yet.

But ten per cent of something worth almost nothing today may be ten per cent of something extremely valuable later. If equity is being given to a founder or key employee in return for a future contribution, founders should think carefully about vesting and what happens when that person leaves.


Someone who works for six months and disappears should not retain exactly the same economic position as someone who spends the next eight years building the company.

Good leaver, bad leaver and vesting provisions are necessary protections.


5. Waiting until a deal to sort out the paperwork


This is a common mistake. Company records are not kept up to date. Share certificates are not issued. IP is never properly transferred to the company. Loans from founders are not recorded. Important agreements with customers and suppliers are never properly written down.


None of this seems terribly important when everyone is busy building the business.

But when an investor or buyer arrives, the things that haven't been done are exactly what they are looking for. Who owns the shares? Who owns the IP? What money is owed to the founders? What contracts does the company have? What rights do its customers have?

Things that could have been sorted out easily at the time suddenly have to be pieced together in the middle of a deal.


It is important that founders keep the basic records straight from the beginning. It saves time, money and trouble later.


Get the basics right

Founders do not need to lawyer the life out of a new business but they should be clear about:

•who owns what;

•who makes which decisions;

•who owns the IP;

•what happens if somebody leaves;

•what happens if the founders fall out; and

•how somebody can eventually sell their shares and leave.


It is much easier to agree these things while everybody is getting along than to fight about what everyone supposedly agreed three years later.


This article provides general information and is not legal advice.


Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page