top of page

Developments in South African mining law: October 2026

Oct 22
7 min read

South African mining law is developing through judgments, environmental regulation and proposed legislation.

The Mining Charter remains policy

In Minerals Council of South Africa v Minister of Mineral Resources and Energy and Others [2021] ZAGPPHC 623, delivered on 21 September 2021, the full court held that section 100(2) of the Mineral and Petroleum Resources Development Act 28 of 2002 (MPRDA) did not empower the Minister to make binding subordinate legislation through the 2018 Mining Charter. It set aside specified provisions, including provisions dealing with renewal and transfer, procurement and enforcement. It did not set aside the whole Charter.

The grant requirements remain relevant, and obligations that have been lawfully incorporated into a particular mining right remain enforceable. The judgment is generally read as supporting the "once empowered, always empowered" principle for existing rights. Buyers and funders should still review the executed right, its conditions and the empowerment history against the legislation, particularly where a renewal, transfer or new application is contemplated, and with the proposed reform in mind.

Section 11 reaches beyond the immediate right holder

In Vantage Goldfields SA (Pty) Ltd and Another v Arqomanzi (Pty) Ltd and Others [2023] ZASCA 106, delivered on 27 June 2023, the Supreme Court of Appeal addressed an indirect change of control through a transaction at ultimate holding-company level. The acquisition of a 98% stake in that company could not be treated as irrelevant merely because the mining rights remained in subsidiaries. The Court interpreted section 11 as extending to direct and indirect transactions of the relevant kind.

A transaction is accordingly not insulated from section 11 only because it occurs higher in the group structure. Subscriptions, dilution and offshore restructuring should be assessed by their practical effect on control of the relevant asset. Minority transfers still require a fact-specific assessment of the statutory language, the transaction structure and the actual control position.

Afrimat: minority interests and remedy for administrative delay

Afrimat Iron Ore (Proprietary) Ltd v Minister of Mineral and Petroleum Resources and Others [2026] ZAGPPHC 403, delivered on 18 May 2026, adds an important qualification. The dispute concerned an outstanding section 11 application and an intervening party who claimed a 34% shareholding in the right holder through her late husband's estate. The Court distinguished the company's right from the shareholder's interest in the company, and held that a shareholder's interest in the company is not an interest in the mining right for the purposes of section 11(1).

Afrimat should be applied with care. It confirms that the section 11 enquiry remains fact-sensitive, particularly where a transaction affects a minority interest rather than control of the right holder. The judgment should be read with Vantage and with the distinction between an interest in a company and a controlling interest in the holder of the mining right.

The case also shows that a failure to take a decision can be challenged. The Court reviewed the failure to decide and granted consequential relief requiring consent and the subsequent cession. The commercial urgency included a deadline for rail-capacity applications. The Director-General granted section 11 consent on 20 May 2026. Leave to appeal the main judgment was refused by the High Court on 17 June 2026 in Mlotshwa v Minister of Mineral and Petroleum Resources and Others [2026] ZAGPPHC 567. A later urgent application to set the consent aside was dismissed on 26 June 2026 in [2026] ZAGPPHC 731, in part because the internal appeal under section 96 of the MPRDA had not been used. Leave to appeal that dismissal was refused on 2 October 2026 in [2026] ZAGPPHC 1089.

The Wild Coast judgment

On 14 August 2026, the Constitutional Court delivered Sustaining the Wild Coast NPC and Others v Minister of Mineral Resources and Energy and Others; Natural Justice and Another v Minister of Mineral Resources and Energy and Others [2026] ZACC 33. The majority set aside the Supreme Court of Appeal's suspension of the High Court order invalidating the exploration right and its renewals. The original setting-aside therefore stood without the proposed renewal-stage rescue.

The defects were not confined to consultation. They included failures to consider relevant environmental and climate-related matters and to comply with applicable legal requirements. The majority rejected the assumption that a consultation exercise during a later renewal could cure all those defects. It also explained that remittal is not an automatic consequence of setting aside an administrative decision.

The minority judgment would have allowed a route to reconsideration with fresh consultation. That is relevant to any careful explanation of the case, but the majority judgment is the binding outcome.

Although the case concerned offshore petroleum exploration, its administrative-law reasoning is important for mining-right due diligence. The original grant and consultation record should be tested as carefully as any renewal or deed. The case also underlines the importance of a proper record on environmental, climate and community-related issues.

The 2025 reform draft

The draft Mineral Resources Development Bill, 2025 was published under GN 6210 in Government Gazette 52704 on 20 May 2025. Its proposed changes cover artisanal and small-scale mining, associated minerals, beneficiation, consultation, sanctions and the wider regulatory framework. An erratum in GN 6298, Government Gazette 52842 of 9 June 2025, corrected important wording concerning section 11 and prospecting-related empowerment provisions.

The position has continued to evolve. Reporting in October 2026 records that the reform was being negotiated at Nedlac and that government and industry described progress in those discussions. These reports are useful indicators of the reform process, but the final legislative position must still be confirmed from the enacted text.

Transaction documents should therefore address regulatory change expressly, including conditions precedent, risk allocation, cooperation obligations and long-stop dates. That is preferable to assuming that the draft will pass unchanged, or that the Nedlac process has removed the risk.

Illegal mining: the August 2026 draft extends to those who assist

The General (Mining) Laws Amendment Bill, 2026 was published for comment on 7 August 2026. It is a separate initiative from the broader 2025 reform. The draft proposes changes to the Criminal Procedure Act, Diamonds Act, MPRDA and Precious Metals Act.

Its proposed section 5B would prohibit direct or indirect assistance or services that enable the activities prohibited by section 5A. The draft also proposes additional police powers and substantially increased penalties, with maximums for some offences of a fine of R100 million, imprisonment of up to 30 years, or both. Those penalties apply only if the relevant provisions are enacted and commenced.

The breadth of the proposed assistance provision deserves attention from contractors, equipment suppliers, transporters and other service providers. The practical response is to build basic legality checks into onboarding, especially where equipment, transport or site services are provided to smaller or less established operators. The file should identify the counterparty, the authority relied on and the agreed scope of work.

The draft also contains an important qualification. Routine inspections and compliance notices are excluded from the police powers conferred automatically by proposed section 91A, although a specific assignment remains possible with the required ministerial concurrence.

Environmental appeals now require the 2025 rules to be checked

The National Appeal Regulations, 2025 were published under GN R5985 on 13 March 2025 and took effect on publication. They replaced the 2014 National Appeal Regulations and the 2016 coastal-management appeal regulations, subject to transitional provisions.

Regulation 4 sets the periods for lodging an appeal, and appeals under section 43(8) of NEMA have a 30-calendar-day period. Regulation 1 contains time-reckoning rules. Pending and legacy matters require the transitional provisions to be checked.

The immediate procedural step is to identify the decision, the appeal route, the triggering communication and any applicable transitional rule. Do not assume a standard period. MPRDA decisions and environmental decisions may have different appeal routes and different deadlines, and the deadline should be calculated from the relevant record.

Rehabilitation funding: transitional relief is not a release from obligations

GN 4296 in Government Gazette 50059 of 1 February 2024 amended regulations 17A and 17B of the 2015 Financial Provisioning Regulations. For the specified holders who applied before 20 November 2015, the notice substituted compliance by a date to be published in the Gazette. In the meantime, the deemed-compliance protection depends on compliance with the financial-provisioning arrangements approved under the relevant MPRDA right or permit.

The qualifying date is the application date, not the age of the mine. The extension also does not remove the need for rehabilitation funding.

The due-diligence exercise should compare the approved arrangements, actual security and current rehabilitation exposure. The May 2026 Centre for Environmental Rights report, No More Ghost Towns, provides policy and implementation context.

Mine health and safety reform is before Parliament

The Mine Health and Safety Amendment Bill B10-2026 was introduced on 7 April 2026 and is under consideration by the National Assembly. Its introduced text proposes stronger executive accountability, changes to training and codes of practice, and stronger enforcement and penalties.

For example, clause 2 would require every employer to appoint a chief executive officer responsible for ensuring that the employer's functions are performed. For a company, that officer would have to be a board member. Other clauses would amend training duties. These remain proposals in the introduced Bill unless and until enacted and commenced.

Critical minerals and cadastre

The 2025 Critical Minerals and Metals Strategy emphasises exploration, value addition, research and skills, infrastructure and energy, finance, and regulatory alignment. It is an important statement of policy direction. Project teams should still verify the ordinary legal building blocks for any specific project, including the right, environmental authorisation and any applicable incentive, condition or restriction.

The cadastre is a separate implementation issue. Reporting on 9 June 2026 attributed a national rollout target of 31 March 2027 to the department's Director-General. That target should be monitored, but it does not replace the need for a complete, reconciled rights file.

What this means for a mining transaction

The starting questions are: who holds the right; what changes in control are proposed; was the grant lawfully made; which obligations bind the holder; which approvals and appeals remain outstanding; and who bears the risk of delay or legal change?

For an existing operation, separate enforceable obligations from policy expectations and proposed reform. For a buyer or funder, connect the transaction documents to the rights, approvals and liabilities that make the asset usable.

This article is a selected overview researched to 19 October 2026. It does not cover every development in mining, environmental, water, labour, tax or petroleum law. It is general information, not advice on any particular transaction. Before publication or reliance, the current legislative status, commencement provisions, appeal position and transitional arrangements should be checked again.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Five mistakes South African founders make

Most founders don't start businesses because they are excited about shareholders' agreements. Legal housekeeping tends to come later. Sometimes much later. Unfortunately, legal problems usually become

 
 
 
Developments in South African family law 2026/2027

People usually resort to family law when a relationship has broken down, financial security is uncertain or decisions about children have become difficult. At that point, advice based on what the law

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page